November 2009 Archives

Cheating and the Importance of Not Condoning It

handball_v03_400px.jpgLife is a game! Games are part of life! Soccer is only a game and I’m not a big enthusiast, but I enjoy watching it from time to time. Like many, I feel bothered by Thierry Henry’s hand ball incident in the Ireland versus France match. All the world saw that the referee and officials made a wrong decision and that France’s win depended on cheating. I don’t in any way blame Thierry Henry. In the heat of the moment he reacted instinctively. All the players in the match were highly fired-up and that is normal in sport. I, like so many others, am bothered because FIFA has effectively condoned cheating as a means of winning football matches. The implication is that if the cheating is not detected by the referee and the officials at the time it occurs, then it is perfectly acceptable to win on that basis. The message is cheat! go ahead, it’s a valid tactic and you might get away with it. What is more, there is huge money involved in international football and the incentives to cheat in all sorts of ways are huge. Of course the rule book supports the FIFA decision, when read selectively! In any set of rules there is a hierarchy of principles, but which principle is the primary one? Is it the principle of fair play? If FIFA’s highest principles were applied to athletics then athletes who were found to have cheated retrospectively through using drugs would not be deprived of their medals. Effectively they would be congratulated for having gotten away with it!

About this Archive

This page is an archive of entries from November 2009 listed from newest to oldest.

January 2010 is the next archive.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.